Intuition & Discernment13 Min Read

Is It Intuition or Fear? What I Have Learned About Trusting My Gut

Lorri Brewer reflects on intuition versus fear, why she ignored a powerful warning, and how experience, evidence and discernment shape trust in her gut.

A winding forest path surrounded by tall pine trees in soft natural light
A quiet path reflects Lorri's image of following one breadcrumb at a time.Photo by Szymon on Pexels

In This Piece

Is It Intuition or Fear? What I Have Learned About Trusting My Gut

Intuition & Discernment / 00613 min read

Journal Navigation

On touch screens, swipe left for older and right for newer.

Several years ago, I had someone in my life whom I trusted completely. This person was a trusted advisor, a soulmate, someone I loved and believed would always protect me. I shared my secrets, my fears, my worries, and the most intimate details of my life. I opened my heart and allowed this person into places I would never ordinarily allow another human being to enter.

Then one day, I experienced an extraordinarily strong intuitive feeling that this person should no longer be part of my life.

I was frightened, not because I didn’t recognize what I was feeling, but because I understood what following it would mean. How could someone I loved and trusted so completely possibly be someone I needed to remove from my life? Was I sensing something important, or was I simply frightened by how vulnerable I had become?

My mind offered plenty of reasons to dismiss the feeling. I knew this person intimately, trusted their judgment, believed in their loyalty, and could not imagine they would ever deliberately hurt me.

I listened to my reasoning instead of my intuition. What followed became the most painful betrayal I have experienced in my lifetime.

I have thought about that experience many times, particularly because intuition and consciousness have been such important parts of my life since my near-death experience in 2010. People sometimes assume that because I have had a near-death experience, I must possess extraordinary intuitive abilities or have answers to questions that other people struggle to understand.

The truth is that I consider myself one of the healthiest skeptics I know. I am constantly trying to find the balance between what I can prove and what I believe.

And even with everything I have experienced, I have made decisions that went against what my intuition was telling me.

Why I Don't Believe Intuition Needs Developing

During my speaking engagements and conversations with people, one of the questions I hear most often is, “How do I develop my intuition?”

I have always found that question interesting because I believe we are approaching intuition from the wrong direction. We assume it is something we must acquire, strengthen, or learn to access. We search for ways to become more intuitive, as though this ability is missing or incomplete and we need to do something extraordinary to activate it.

From my spiritual perspective, intuition is already an inherent part of who we are. I believe it is as natural to us as the consciousness through which we experience our lives.

I don’t believe we need to develop our intuition. I believe we need to understand why we so often refuse to act on it.

Think about the number of times you have experienced a strong feeling about a situation, a relationship, or a decision, only to begin questioning yourself moments later. Perhaps something felt wrong, but you couldn’t explain why. Perhaps you recognized that a change was necessary, but the consequences frightened you.

What happens between that initial feeling and the decision you eventually make?

My experience has taught me that the difficulty often begins after the intuitive feeling arrives. My mind becomes involved, and suddenly I am trying to reconcile what I initially sensed with everything I know, everything I fear, and everything I might lose.

That is where intuition becomes complicated for me.

When the Yappy Mind Takes Over

I describe the experience of being aligned with my intuition as a kind of flow. There is a calmness to it, almost like the calm before a storm. Even when I don’t know what will happen next, I am not consumed with needing to control every possible outcome. I am present, attentive, and able to recognize what I believe are synchronicities unfolding around me.

I sometimes imagine myself walking along a path where breadcrumbs are falling into place. I don’t need to see where the entire path leads. I only need to recognize the breadcrumb directly in front of me. I pick it up, take another step, and discover what comes next.

When I am living that way, I often find that opportunities, conversations, and circumstances begin to connect in ways I couldn’t have planned. I experience those moments as a relationship between intuition, consciousness, and the unfolding circumstances of my life.

But the experience changes when my mind becomes consumed with everything that might go wrong.

I begin thinking about the past, remembering disappointments, mistakes, and experiences that caused me pain. Then I start projecting myself into the future, imagining circumstances that haven’t happened and outcomes I cannot possibly predict. Before long, the decision in front of me has become tangled up with every worry my mind can produce.

I call this the yappy mind. It is the part of my thinking that insists on examining every possibility, particularly the frightening ones, until I become so overwhelmed by uncertainty that making a decision feels almost impossible.

I picture intuition and fear sitting at opposite ends of a spectrum. When that spectrum becomes very short, the two seem to overlap. The intuitive feeling is still there, but fear has become so involved in my interpretation of it that I struggle to separate what I initially sensed from everything I am frightened might happen.

For me, the answer begins with lengthening that spectrum. I try to become still, return my attention to the present, and give myself enough room to understand what I am experiencing.

Gratitude helps me remain in that present moment. Instead of demanding certainty about a future I cannot control, I return to the next breadcrumb and the decision that is actually mine to make.

An open notebook, pen and coffee cup on a light tabletop

A quiet moment can create room to examine a difficult decision. Photo by Cup of Couple on Pexels

When I Knew I Wanted to Change My Life

One of the most significant examples of this in my professional life involved my decision to close my real estate brokerage and pursue my speaking and writing career.

I had spent nearly three decades working in real estate. It was a profession I knew extremely well, and it had provided the foundation for much of my adult life. I understood the financial responsibilities of running a business, the importance of planning, and the consequences of making major professional decisions.

Yet approximately two years before I finally made the change, I experienced a strong intuitive knowing that it was time to move in a different direction. I wanted to bring my speaking and writing to a much larger audience. My book Heaven Time had a message I believed deserved to be heard, and I had another book waiting to be introduced.

Intuitively, I knew what I wanted to do. The direction felt clear, and I believed I could find my way through it.

The uncertainty arrived when I began thinking about everything involved in carrying out that decision. I considered what I would be leaving behind, what needed to be organized, what might go wrong, and whether I could manage the transition successfully.

Some of those concerns were entirely legitimate. Closing a business requires serious thought and responsible planning. But I can also recognize how fear, worry, avoidance, and overcompensating became mixed into the process.

It took approximately two years for my logical thinking to catch up with the direction I had already recognized.

I find that remarkable. My years in business had taught me the importance of making informed decisions, yet I could see how easily I was using further planning to postpone something I already believed was right for me.

There is a difference between recognizing the responsibilities attached to a decision and allowing those responsibilities to become reasons never to make it.

I had to be honest with myself about which one I was doing.

The Warning I Wasn't Ready to Face

My experience with the person I trusted taught me something different and considerably more painful.

When I sensed that this relationship had become harmful to me, I didn’t want to consider the possibility that my feeling might be justified. I had shared so much of myself with this person that the thought of ending the relationship was almost unbearable.

I kept returning to everything I believed about them: the trust we had established, the intimacy we shared, and the certainty I had felt that this was someone who would never betray me.

I had warning signs that deserved my attention, but I allowed my attachment to what I believed about the relationship to override them.

Looking back, I can see how much influence fear had over my decision. I was frightened of losing the relationship, frightened of being wrong about someone I loved, and frightened of what ending that connection might mean.

Rather than examine those concerns honestly, I kept finding reasons to preserve what I wanted to believe.

The eventual betrayal left me devastated. One of the most difficult parts was knowing that I had experienced a powerful concern long before I was willing to examine it.

I am careful about how I interpret that experience today. An intuitive feeling cannot prove another person’s intentions, and feeling certain about something does not automatically make it true. I would never suggest that people accuse or condemn someone based solely on a gut feeling.

But I also believe we owe ourselves the opportunity to investigate our concerns, pay attention to what is happening, and acknowledge when something no longer feels right.

What I regret is that I didn’t give myself that opportunity. I dismissed what I was experiencing because accepting it would have required me to face something I desperately wanted to avoid.

People often speak about intuition as though it is a quiet whisper that we have to strain to hear. That hasn’t always been my experience. Sometimes my intuition has been extraordinarily strong. It has been every bit as loud as my fear.

The challenge has been deciding what to do when both demand my attention.

Can Intuition Be Wrong?

This is an important question, particularly because I don’t believe we should treat every strong feeling as unquestionable truth.

Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein explored the conditions under which intuitive judgments can be reliable. Their research examined why people sometimes make remarkably accurate judgments without consciously working through every detail, while at other times their confidence leads them in the wrong direction.

They found that reliable intuitive expertise depends partly on whether a person has had opportunities to recognize meaningful patterns and learn from feedback. A powerful feeling of certainty, by itself, does not establish that a judgment is correct.

Their research on intuitive expertise offers an interesting distinction between having an intuitive impression and knowing whether that impression deserves our confidence.

I find that distinction important.

My years in business gave me considerable experience evaluating people, circumstances, negotiations, and professional decisions. I learned to recognize certain patterns because I had encountered similar situations before. Some of what I might describe as intuition in those circumstances may also reflect experience and judgment operating faster than conscious reasoning.

But professional experience does not make me an expert in every part of life, and recognizing patterns does not guarantee that my interpretation is correct.

The same caution applies to relationships. A feeling may deserve attention without establishing why another person is behaving a certain way.

I don’t want to dismiss my intuition simply because I cannot explain it. I also don’t want to mistake the strength of a feeling for proof that I have understood a situation correctly.

For me, the responsibility is to remain curious enough to investigate what I am experiencing.

What I Believe About Consciousness and Intuition

My understanding of intuition is inseparable from my near-death experience on September 19, 2010. That experience profoundly changed how I understand consciousness, the physical body, and what I believe exists beyond death.

I believe consciousness survives the termination of the physical body. I also believe that intuition is connected to our consciousness and to a divine source or higher creator. To me, intuition is an energetic part of our existence, something inherent within us that I understand as guiding us toward our highest good.

These are deeply held spiritual beliefs shaped by what I experienced and the years I have spent reflecting upon it.

I recognize that my understanding of intuition is not the same as a scientific explanation of how intuitive judgments occur.

I am not trying to persuade people that every feeling they experience is an infallible message from a spiritual source. My personal understanding comes from my lived experience and my beliefs about consciousness. I can speak about that experience without claiming that science has established the spiritual explanation I give to it.

For me, this is where discernment becomes essential. I want to remain open to what I experience while being honest about what I know, what I believe, and what I cannot prove.

The fact that I have had a near-death experience doesn’t remove my responsibility to question my interpretations. If anything, it has made those questions more important to me.

The Space Between Knowing and Acting

When someone asks how to become more intuitive, I often wonder what happens when they already have a strong feeling about something but are frightened of what acting on it might mean.

Have they recognized that something in their life needs to change but continued delaying because the consequences feel overwhelming? Have they talked themselves out of examining a concern because acknowledging it would mean facing a difficult truth?

Those questions interest me because they concern what we actually do with the experiences we have.

I believe we can become so occupied with our thoughts that we lose our connection with the present moment. We revisit yesterday, worry about tomorrow, and try to solve circumstances that haven’t happened. Meanwhile, something important in our present circumstances may be asking for our attention.

That doesn’t mean we should abandon reason or stop considering evidence. Fear can alert us to genuine danger, and practical concerns deserve attention.

If we feel something is wrong with our health, for example, we shouldn’t use intuition as a substitute for medical care. We should investigate the concern. If we are questioning a relationship, we can observe behaviour, ask difficult questions, and establish boundaries without assuming we know another person’s private intentions.

I believe acting on intuition can include those very practical steps. It can mean taking a concern seriously enough to investigate it or acknowledging that something deserves our attention even when we are uncomfortable with what we might discover.

Some of the most difficult experiences of my life have taught me things I might never have learned if every decision had worked out exactly as I hoped. I wouldn’t wish suffering on anyone, and I don’t believe every painful experience arrives for some predetermined reason. But I do believe we can find meaning in how we respond to what has happened.

I still consider myself a skeptic. I still ask questions, consider evidence, and recognize that my interpretations can be wrong. I also continue to believe that intuition is an inherent part of who we are, connected to a consciousness that I understand as extending beyond this physical life.

I don’t feel a need to spend the rest of my life trying to make my intuition stronger. I want to become more attentive to the ways fear, attachment, and uncertainty influence the decisions I make.

When I think about the betrayal I experienced, I cannot know whether acting on my initial concern would have prevented what happened. What I do know is that I spent a considerable amount of effort explaining away something that deserved my attention.

That is what I want to do differently.

I want to be present enough to recognize what I am experiencing, consider what I can verify, and give myself permission to investigate a concern even when I would prefer to believe everything is fine.

And when something within me is ringing loudly, I no longer want to dismiss it simply because following it may be uncomfortable.

After everything I have experienced, I have come to understand that the most difficult part of intuition is sometimes the space between what we believe we know and what we are willing to do about it.

More From The Journal

Keep reading.

01Decisions & ClarityWould You Buy a Home Where Someone Died?02Identity & ChangeWhat My Real Estate Career Taught Me About Listening and Success03Grief & LossYou Cannot Fix Someone's Grief. You Can Sit Beside It.

Free Membership

Stay connected.

Create a free member account for full Journal access, monthly live member events and the private Facebook Community. You can opt in to Lorri's Newsletter if you'd like updates.

Join Free Membership