Decisions & Clarity15 Min Read

Would You Buy a Home Where Someone Died?

I spent 29 years in real estate. A troubling townhouse taught me why a home's history can matter just as much as what a building inspection reveals.

White residential house on a quiet street beneath an overcast sky
The history of an ordinary-looking house may influence how different buyers feel about calling it home.Photo by Erik Mclean on Pexels

In This Piece

Would You Buy a Home Where Someone Died?

Decisions & Clarity / 00715 min read

Journal Navigation

On touch screens, swipe left for older and right for newer.

There was a townhouse in Alberta that had become extraordinarily difficult to rent. Several owners had come and gone, tenants had broken their leases, and the property’s reputation had followed it from one transaction to the next. A homicide had occurred there years earlier, followed by other tragic deaths. Some former occupants had reported hearing voices, seeing apparitions, and feeling deeply uncomfortable in the home.

By the time a property management company contacted me, the usual approaches to managing the property had not resolved the situation. They wanted to know whether I could help.

I had spent nearly three decades in real estate, but this was hardly the kind of property I would have wanted to deal with at the beginning of my career. Back then, I had a much more practical approach to making money. I wanted homes I could sell, buyers who could purchase them, and transactions that would actually close.

I was a single mother earning a living in a competitive industry. Taking on properties that might sit on the market indefinitely was not an appealing business strategy.

Yet after my near-death experience in 2010, I found myself becoming involved in a part of the real estate industry I had previously given very little thought to: stigmatized properties.

And what fascinated me wasn’t simply the history of these homes. It was how differently people responded to that history, what happened when important information was withheld, and how little the usual measurements of a property’s value could tell us about whether someone would feel comfortable living there.

How I Became Involved in Stigmatized Properties

For most of my early real estate career, I worked primarily with residential homes and acreages. I was concerned with the location, condition, construction, price, financing, and marketability of a property. I knew how to evaluate comparable sales, negotiate a transaction, and identify the practical considerations that could affect a buyer’s decision.

Whether someone had previously died in a home rarely entered those conversations.

I had encountered properties where deaths had occurred, but unless there was a physical issue affecting the property or a buyer raised the question, I didn’t consider the death relevant to its construction or condition. I didn’t make it a subject of discussion.

That was how I approached real estate at the time.

After my near-death experience on September 19, 2010, my professional life took an unexpected direction. I stepped away from the industry for a period, sold my brokerage, wrote my book Heaven Time, and began speaking publicly about death, dying, grief, intuition, consciousness, and my understanding of what happens when we leave this physical life.

Those subjects interested me because I was trying to understand my own extraordinary experience and everything that had changed in my life afterward.

During my speaking engagements, people started approaching me with real estate questions I hadn’t expected.

They owned properties where something tragic had happened. Some were struggling to sell their homes. Others were working with real estate professionals who didn’t know how to approach the property’s history or the concerns of potential purchasers.

Often, they weren’t asking me to sell the property. They wanted a referral to someone I trusted who could help them. They were tired of reducing their asking price and hoping that eventually somebody would purchase the home.

I understood their frustration. I also recognized that the concerns they were describing required a different kind of conversation.

A real estate professional is trained to deal with what I call the sticks and bricks: the structure, the land, the financial numbers, and the comparable sales. Most professionals are understandably reluctant to become involved in conversations about spiritual beliefs, vibrational energy, house cleansings, or alleged paranormal experiences.

Those subjects are outside the usual scope of real estate practice.

But they can be very important to the person making the largest purchase of their life.

Over time, I became involved in helping other real estate professionals and property owners navigate these unusual circumstances. I was also interviewed about stigmatized properties and the responsibilities of the real estate industry, including for a Canadian Real Estate Association article exploring the subject.

What began as an unexpected intersection between my professional experience and my personal understanding of death became an area of real estate that I found genuinely fascinating.

A House Can Be Structurally Sound and Still Be Difficult to Sell

One of the most misunderstood aspects of stigmatized real estate is the difference between a physical problem with a property and a concern about its history.

Imagine walking into a beautiful home. It has the right number of bedrooms, a wonderful kitchen, a lovely backyard, and everything your family needs. The inspection finds no major concerns. The price is within your budget, and you can picture yourself living there.

Then somebody tells you that a person was murdered in the primary bedroom.

For some people, that information changes absolutely everything. They no longer want to see the property, never mind purchase it. They may be disturbed by the thought of sleeping in the room where a violent death occurred. Their religious or spiritual beliefs may make them uncomfortable, or they may simply find the history too upsetting to contemplate.

Another buyer might hear exactly the same information and be completely unaffected. They may have no concerns about the home’s history, particularly if the property is well maintained and available at an attractive price.

Neither buyer has to justify their reaction to the other.

This is what makes a stigmatized property so unusual. Its physical condition might be identical for both purchasers, but their perception of its desirability can be entirely different.

Bright, empty home interior with hardwood floors and natural daylight

A house can be physically sound while its history affects how prospective buyers see it. Photo by Curtis Adams on Pexels

In Alberta, the Real Estate Council of Alberta distinguishes between a property stigma and a material latent defect. A stigma concerns something that may make a property less desirable without necessarily affecting its physical condition. A material latent defect is a serious problem that cannot be identified through a reasonable inspection and meets the regulatory criteria, such as making a property dangerous or unsuitable for its intended use.

A death or a disturbing history does not automatically become a material latent defect simply because it makes someone uncomfortable. Known material latent defects must be disclosed, while a stigma generally does not carry the same automatic disclosure requirement. Sellers may decline to answer questions about a stigma, but if they choose to answer, the information must be truthful. Real estate professionals must also respect their duties to clients, including confidentiality and the obligation to investigate relevant concerns when representing buyers.

Understanding those distinctions is essential. They are also a good illustration of why the legal minimum and a buyer’s personal concerns may not always line up neatly.

I believe buyers should have a meaningful opportunity to investigate a property’s history before becoming emotionally or financially committed to it. If a person would never consider living in a home where a homicide occurred, I would rather understand that before we arrange a viewing than discover it after they have fallen in love with the house.

I also recognize the responsibilities owed to sellers and the importance of handling sensitive information lawfully and accurately.

A real estate professional’s job includes understanding what matters to the people involved. That requires asking questions rather than assuming every buyer evaluates a property in the same way.

A house can be perfectly sound from a construction standpoint and still be completely wrong for a particular person.

The Townhouse That Changed Hands Repeatedly

One of the more difficult situations I encountered involved a townhouse where a homicide had occurred approximately ten years before I became involved.

The property’s history was disturbing. According to the account shared with me, the owner following the homicide had sold under considerable emotional pressure, and the property changed hands at a low price. An investor purchased it, made renovations, and rented it to a tenant without discussing the earlier tragedy.

The tenant subsequently reported unsettling experiences in the home, including apparitions, and later died by suicide. Another investor eventually purchased the property and rented it to a family. There were further difficulties during that tenancy, including another death by suicide.

Over the following years, the property continued passing between investors. Tenants reportedly complained about noises, voices, and frightening experiences. Several moved out before completing their leases.

I want to be clear about something important. Those deaths were tragic events involving real human beings. Reports of unusual experiences do not establish that a property was haunted, nor do they explain why someone died by suicide. I would never claim that an unseen force caused those deaths.

What I can describe is the situation as it was presented to me and the difficulties that arose as the property’s history became increasingly well known.

By the time the property management company contacted me, they were having serious trouble maintaining tenancies. The home had already been visited by several people offering spiritual or energetic assistance, including a priest, a shaman, and an Indigenous spiritual practitioner.

I was asked to become involved because of my combined experience in real estate and my personal understanding of spiritual and energetic practices.

I visited the property and performed what I describe as a house cleansing. For me, that is a spiritual practice intended to address the atmosphere of a home and the experiences of the people connected to it. It is not a building inspection, a mental-health intervention, or a scientifically established remedy for unusual occurrences.

Ultimately, the property management company recognized that continuing to rent the townhouse was not the right approach, and the decision was made to sell.

I helped the people involved navigate the circumstances, including the difficult history and the concerns surrounding the property. I was also introduced to the eventual buyers, and the history was discussed with them rather than concealed.

The home was sold, and a young family moved in. To my knowledge, they continued living there without the problems that earlier occupants had reported.

I cannot tell you that the cleansing caused that outcome. There were several factors involved, including the decision to sell, the buyers’ understanding of the property’s history, and their willingness to make it their home.

What I found significant was that a property considered deeply troubling by some people could eventually become a comfortable place to live for others.

The building itself had not ceased to exist. Its history had not changed. The buyers had made an informed decision about what that history meant to them.

What We Feel in a Home

My understanding of a home extends beyond its physical construction.

Based on my personal experiences, particularly since my near-death experience, I believe that the land, the building, the objects inside it, and the people who occupy it each contribute to what I describe as the home’s energetic or vibrational atmosphere.

Sometimes those elements seem to come together comfortably. Other times, the atmosphere feels unsettled or incompatible with the people living there.

I recognize that this is a spiritual interpretation drawn from my own experience. The energetic qualities I am describing are not something a home inspector can measure, and there is no established scientific basis for concluding that a previous death leaves a detectable spiritual imprint on a property.

Nevertheless, the way people experience a home matters to them.

Some people tell me they can sense something uncomfortable immediately upon entering a property. Others are completely unaffected by the same surroundings. There are also people who initially love a house but become distressed after learning about its history.

I don’t believe we should dismiss a person’s discomfort simply because we cannot explain it. Equally, I don’t believe we should treat an uncomfortable feeling as evidence that something supernatural is present.

There are many reasons someone may feel uneasy in a particular place, including its appearance, sounds, associations, memories, or information they have learned about it.

My interest is in helping people understand their own response and make decisions they are comfortable with.

This is also why I wouldn’t automatically reject a home because someone had died there. I believe the atmosphere of a home can change as new people move in, establish their routines, care for the property, and create their own experiences. I also use personal spiritual practices that I believe contribute to how my home feels.

I don’t need to erase a property’s history in order to feel comfortable living there.

Which brings me to another question that I find even more challenging.

Should We Demolish a Home Because Something Terrible Happened There?

When I learned that the house where four University of Idaho students were murdered had been demolished, I had mixed feelings.

The murders of Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin in November 2022 were devastating. The loss of those young lives affected their families, their friends, the university, and people far beyond Idaho.

The off-campus house where they were killed was demolished on December 28, 2023, before the criminal case was resolved. Some relatives opposed the demolition, while university officials and others believed removing the building would help the community move forward. The prosecution and defence had been given access to the property, and authorities had documented the scene before demolition. Bryan Kohberger subsequently pleaded guilty to the murders in July 2025 and received four life sentences without parole. The events and differing views surrounding the demolition were documented by Associated Press.

I understand why somebody who has suffered a terrible loss might want the building removed. Seeing the place where a loved one was killed could be unbearable. I also understand why some family members might want the structure preserved, particularly while legal proceedings remain unresolved.

Those are deeply personal responses, and I would never presume to tell grieving families how they should feel.

What concerns me is the broader assumption that demolishing a structure is necessarily the best response to the tragedy that occurred there.

That house was the location of a terrible crime, but before that crime it was also a home. People celebrated birthdays, shared meals, laughed with friends, and created ordinary memories inside those walls. Four young people lost their lives there, and the final moments of their lives became forever associated with that place.

When a building comes down, its physical presence disappears. But the event remains part of the community’s history, and the people who loved those who died continue carrying their memories.

From my spiritual perspective, I also believe that removing the structure does not necessarily erase the energetic history associated with the land. That is my belief, rather than something I can demonstrate scientifically.

I sometimes think about churches. We gather in them for funerals, surrounded by grief and the pain of saying goodbye. Yet those same buildings may also be places where people celebrate weddings, welcome children, and experience some of the happiest moments of their lives.

We don’t usually regard a church as permanently defined by every funeral that has taken place inside it.

Why, then, should a house always be defined by the worst thing that happened there?

The question becomes even more complicated when we consider tragedies in schools, restaurants, shopping centres, and other public places. Violence can occur in buildings that serve entire communities. We cannot reasonably assume that every structure associated with a tragic death must be demolished.

There will be circumstances where demolition is appropriate, necessary, or genuinely supported by those most affected. Safety, legal evidence, the wishes of families, community needs, and the condition of the building all deserve careful consideration.

But I believe we should examine those decisions rather than automatically equating the destruction of a building with the removal of grief or fear.

If we can find ways to acknowledge what happened, honour those who died, and help people reclaim a sense of comfort and control, preserving a place may sometimes be worth considering.

Would I Buy a Home Where Someone Died?

Yes, I would.

I would consider buying a home where someone had died naturally, where a suicide had occurred, or even where a violent crime had taken place. I would want to understand the history, the property’s condition, and any genuine safety concerns. I would carry out the same practical due diligence that I would expect in any real estate transaction.

But the fact that somebody died there would not, by itself, prevent me from living in the home.

That answer comes from both my professional experience and my personal beliefs.

After 29 years in real estate, I understand that a home is a physical asset. It has land, a structure, a market value, operating costs, and characteristics that influence what someone is willing to pay. Those practical considerations are important.

I also believe a home is shaped by the people who live in it and the experiences they create.

A family might look at a property with a tragic history and feel that they could never be comfortable there. I respect that entirely. Another family might recognize the tragedy, acknowledge what happened, and still see the opportunity to build a wonderful life within those same walls.

I respect that decision too.

What matters to me is that the people involved are treated honestly, their concerns are taken seriously, and their decisions are made with an appropriate understanding of the circumstances.

I don’t believe buyers should be pressured to dismiss their beliefs, nor should they be frightened into accepting explanations that cannot be substantiated. They deserve accurate information, professional guidance, and the freedom to decide what feels right for them.

That is where I believe real estate professionals have an important responsibility. We are dealing with far more than measurements, mortgage approvals, and closing dates. We are helping people choose the place where they intend to live their lives.

The townhouse that brought me into one of the more challenging situations of my career ultimately became a home for another family. Its past did not disappear when they moved in, but that past did not have to determine every experience they would have there in the future.

That is the part of stigmatized real estate that continues to interest me.

When someone asks whether they should purchase a home where a person died, I understand why they want a straightforward answer. After everything I have seen and experienced, I don’t believe there is one answer that belongs to everybody.

I would buy the home if it suited my needs, was safe, and felt right for me.

Someone else might walk away, and that could be exactly the right decision for them.

After nearly three decades in real estate, I have come to believe that a property’s history deserves consideration, but the people who will live there deserve a voice in deciding what that history means.

A house has a past. The people who make it their home will also give it a future.

More From The Journal

Keep reading.

01Decisions & ClarityWhen I Cannot See What Comes Next, I Come Back to the Decision in Front of Me02Intuition & DiscernmentIs It Intuition or Fear? What I Have Learned About Trusting My Gut03Identity & ChangeWhat My Real Estate Career Taught Me About Listening and Success

Notes & Sources

Sources and further reading

  1. Real Estate Council of Alberta: Stigmatized Properties, The Regulator — RECA's seller/client and buyer guidance about property stigma, truthful answers and the option not to answer.
  2. RECA: Material Latent Defects — Regulatory guidance regarding material latent defects, buyer due diligence and seller disclosure responsibilities.
  3. ABC News: Idaho college murders timeline — Chronology confirming demolition on December 28, 2023, and differing family reactions.
  4. CBS News: Idaho student murders and sentencing timeline — Reporting confirming the July 2025 guilty plea and four life sentences.

Free Membership

Stay connected.

Create a free member account for full Journal access, monthly live member events and the private Facebook Community. You can opt in to Lorri's Newsletter if you'd like updates.

Join Free Membership